Why Negotiating with Defiant Kids Won’t Work
|
If you're new here you might want to check out our top recommendation for parents. You can get a copy of The Total Transformation Program for free for a limited time, and it truly is a fantastic resource. |
You’re probably familiar with the concept of governments not negotiating with terrorists, right? Many countries have decided to take on this policy for one reason – it is effective.
Well, think of your child as that terrorist – making a demand. You are the government. A definition from Wikipedia states that “Common definitions of terrorism refer only to those violent acts which are intended to create fear (terror), are perpetrated for an ideological goal (as opposed to a lone attack), and deliberately target or disregard the safety of non-combatants (civilians)”.
Defiant kids can become abusive and disregard who gets hurt in the process. Just like the terrorists, they think that the world is unfair and they want others to suffer because they are suffering. At least, this is the belief they often hold onto, whether they are consciously aware of it or not. They may be suffering on the inside, but nobody has the right to harm another person. So, negotiating with your kids is not the answer. But why is that?It’s because negotiation will only give them more power. They’ll think that you will be open to negotiate anything, especially when they start to make threats.
As a parent, you would love to make life easier for your kids. I know, I feel the same way too. During years when your kid is young, you may have said, “You should clean your room” or “You should do your homework”. Then they start asking, “Mom, can I do it tomorrow instead?”. This seems harmless at first, so you agree. But if this becomes a pattern, your child will unconsciously learn that everything can be negotiated. Every time you tell your child to do something, they will negotiate because you allowed it to happen often before.
If your child is defiant and always negotiates with you, this is a problem. He will find every way possible to get around your requests. If he is unsuccessful, he starts threatening. He threatens to become violent, threatens with tantrum-like behavior, or to be angry at you. And to think, all you wanted was a quiet and relaxing evening. So even when your gut says “don’t give in!” you do, hoping the negotiation will bring you the relaxation you want. In the long term, this simply makes things worse.
Because you love your child so much, you become lenient and soft. You have to bear in mind if you’ve been doing this for a while and you are not getting results. You need to learn how toughen up and resist the urge to give in to your child’s whims.
There are many parenting skills that you can learn to overcome these problems. Don’t ever fall into the trap of thinking that you won’t ever be able to learn new tricks. Believe me…you can.
Dealing with defiant children can sometimes take a toll on us. I have found a program that successfully teaches you the skills you need to learn. Get a copy of The Total Transformation by James Lehman.
